Essentials & Pies + Fresh Turkeys to Roast
We make Thanksgiving meals easy with our gourmet menus! We offer fresh, all natural turkeys from Sensenig Turkey Farm in Lititz, PA. These come as whole turkeys, bone in turkey breasts or boneless turkey breasts. Choose from our menus of essentials house-made from scratch by our chefs and pies baked fresh in our bakery.
Pre-orders begin October 30th. Pies must be ordered by November 22. All Pre-orders will be in-store pickup based on a time-slot of your choosing. A deposit of $10 per order will be due at checkout.
FAQsPlease note: if an item sells out, it will either no longer appear as an option, or it will be marked as out of stock.
Please select a pickup time (required):
Fresh Turkeys
Essentials
Pies
Apple Caramel Walnut
Chunks of Ida Red apples with a rich caramel topping and crunchy chopped walnuts
Country Cinnamon Apple
Juicy apple slices with an extra pinch of cinnamon and brown sugar inside a crust top
Pecan
A rich blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs & pecans in a sweet custard
Black Cherry
Sweet, juicy dark cherries in a lattice crust topped pie
Very Berry
Four different types of berries - strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries
Blueberry Peach
Two favorite fruit flavors combined
Peach
Juicy peaches with crust top
Peach Praline
Sun ripened peaches topped with rich praline and crunchy pecans
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sweet juicy strawberries and tart rhubarb
Pumpkin
A traditional lightly spiced holiday pie
Apple
A classic with crisp Michigan Apples and a hint of cinnamon
Dutch Apple
Michigan apples with a rich & crunchy streusel topping
Cherry Crumb
Tart cherries with a sweet streusel crumb
Cherry
A tender flaky crust topped pie
Blueberry Crumb
Northern blueberries with a streusel crumb top
Fruits of the Forest
A tasty mix of strawberries, apples, raspberries, rhubarb and blackberries with a crust top
Wild Berry Pie with Zesty Lemon Crust
A mix of blueberries, blackberries & cranberries with a lemon zest top and bottom crust
FAQ
Are all pre-orders going to be picked up in store?
Yes, you will choose an available time slot for pickup when placing your order.
How will the in store pickup work?
On the day of pickup our staff will be assembling orders by time slot. Please do not arrive before your scheduled time slot as we may not have your items ready and it could cause unnecessary delays for others who have arrived in their correct time slot.
Follow the signage to the designated pickup area and give our staff person the name and phone number your order was placed under. We will bring your order to you and check you through the register as efficiently as possible.
What if I am late and miss my pre-booked time slot?
Please let our staff member know that you missed your time slot when you arrive and they will know what to do. DO NOT call ahead to let us know you will not be on time, just let us know when you get here.
Will I need to leave a deposit for my order?
Yes, there is a $10.00 deposit for each item preordered. The deposit(s) will be deducted from your final total. Your final total will be available at the time of pickup.
Why isn't the final price on my pre-order receipt?
Some items are calculated by weight. While the per pound price will not vary, the finished weight of the item cannot be exactly determined at the time of ordering.
Why can I only order prepared foods in whole pound quantities, not half pounds?
We have needed to find efficiencies where we can. We have found by packaging in one size we are able to maintain product quality and gain efficiency. This allows us to take more orders. There is, however, a limit to how much we will be able to make and there is a strong possibility that we will sell out before orders close.
Why can't I place an order for prepared vegetables?
Our chefs use fresh vegetables. Sometimes there are difficulties obtaining the quality they prefer around the holidays. Our chefs would like the flexibility to decide what to make based on vegetable availability and quality just before the holiday. The vegetables they make will be available in store, in the chef's case, on Tuesday and Wednesday.
What will your store hours be on pickup days?
Tuesday 11/26; Store is open from 10:00 am to 6:00 pm.
Wednesday 11/27; Store is open 9:00 am to 6:00 pm.
Store is closed on Thursday 11/28 and Friday 11/29.
Store is open on Saturday 11/30 10 am to 6 pm.
What if I need to make a change to my order?
We understand that changes happen, and we want to get your order right. We prefer that any changes you would like to make are emailed to . Then, please be sure to look for an email confirmation of your order change and item availability from us.
If you prefer to make the changes in person we will be able to handle changes and confirm availability in store.
